A courtroom artist’s view of the Epic v. Apple trial


On Monday, attorneys gave final statements in the Epic v. Apple case, ending up simply over three weeks of in-court proceedings that gave an unprecedented have a look at how Apple manages the iOS App Retailer. Each pictures and audio from the proceedings had been tightly managed (as is usually the case in federal courtrooms), so the one pictures got here from courtroom artist Vicki Behringer, who noticed a lot of the trial from an assigned seat to the best of the jury field. We invited Behringer to share eight of her favourite sketches from the trial, exhibiting off each her ability as an artist and her distinctive perspective on the case. -Russell Brandom, coverage editor




Katherine Forrest gives opening remarks at the Epic v. Apple trial





Picture courtesy of Vicki Behringer


This exhibits opening statements by Epic Video games lawyer Katherine Forrest. It was my first day on the trial and my first sketch. There have been plexiglass obstacles throughout the courtroom as a COVID precaution, and the attorneys wore plastic shields masking their faces. Once I noticed this graphic, exhibiting a wall being constructed across the iPhone, I began to know what was at stake on this trial.




Epic CEO Tim Sweeney on the stand, protected by a plexiglass shield.





Picture courtesy of Vicki Behringer


Epic CEO Tim Sweeney is the one which began this entire case, so I knew his testimony was going to be fascinating. I simply liked listening to how he began the corporate and what the sport Fortnite is all about. I had no concept. As soon as once more, I notice there’s one other total world that I do know nothing about. The programming, creativity, and expertise it takes to create these video games completely amazes me.

I attempt to end all my sketches inside one to at least one and a half hours. Some take longer. I’ve to finances my time whereas I’m sketching within the courtroom. I’ve very strict deadlines and for the reason that information is now a 24-hour cycle with the web, my media shoppers want their sketches as quickly as attainable to go along with their tales.








Picture courtesy of Vicki Behringer


I’ve sketched Phil Schiller two or 3 times now within the Apple v. Samsung trials, so his face appears like an outdated pal. I at all times love listening to him discuss concerning the historical past of Apple. I took my time right here and determined to sketch the whole courtroom. Clearly it isn’t to scale. The variety of individuals allowed within the courtroom was severely lowered, however there have been nonetheless many, many attorneys to sketch, and each time a witness modified, they’d play musical chairs.




Apple executive Mike Schmid appears before the court.





Picture courtesy of Vicki Behringer


That is Mike Schmid, the top of Apple’s gaming division, questioned by Apple lawyer Jay Srinivasan. Seeing as I’m not a gamer, the entire great paintings that goes into the video games is kind of pleasant for me, however I needed to transfer so quick that there wasn’t time to sketch it. Schmid was grilled fairly exhausting on the cross-examination by Epic’s lawyer, however on the break they each relaxed and appeared to be glad to see one another. Perhaps they had been simply glad to have gotten by means of it.




Craig Federighi addresses the court





Picture courtesy of Vicki Behringer


Craig Federighi was an exquisite topic along with his good white hair and darkish eyebrows. Individuals with refined options are far tougher, however Craig was a pleasure. He mentioned the precautions that Apple takes to stop its customers from malware, viruses, and the like. I make a psychological word to at all times replace my software program!




Tim Cook gestures evocatively towards Judge Yvonne Gonzales Rogers





Drawn by Vicki Behringer


I like this sketch as a result of not solely did I get a unique angle on Tim Prepare dinner’s face (which is implausible), but it surely was an necessary second in his testimony. Choose Gonzalez Rogers was asking some actually fascinating questions of him which didn’t sound very favorable towards Apple. His confidence appeared to waver only a bit, however he answered the questions clearly and did his greatest to justify Apple‘s place. It felt like a pivotal level within the trial.

I wished to place in a gesture with the decide’s hand, however didn’t really feel I had sufficient time. Generally palms can take so long as drawing the face.




An expert witness addresses the court, and a pie chart detailing malware infection data is displayed in the lower left-hand corner of the drawing.





Picture courtesy of Vicki Behringer


The second week was largely skilled witnesses. I just like the sketch as a result of this professor had some fascinating issues to say about how protected Apple units had been. I do know he’s an Apple witness, but when his statistics are right, it’s fairly superb! Within the sketch, I added a few different individuals within the courtroom that I often don’t have time to incorporate. The courtroom reporter and the decide’s deputy. When I’m doing an precise trial, I attempt to verify I get a sketch of everybody within the courtroom in some unspecified time in the future. Everyone seems to be necessary, even when they don’t seem to be one of many principal attorneys or witnesses.




A wider view of Tim Cook’s testimony, including legal representatives from both sides at the edges of the frame.





Picture courtesy of Vicki Behringer


That is when Tim Prepare dinner first took the stand, being questioned on direct by Apple lawyer Veronica Moyé. I used to be so nervous whereas sketching him as a result of I knew it needed to look precisely like him; everybody is aware of what Tim Prepare dinner seems to be like. I had studied some pictures of him and thought I used to be prepared. Sadly, when he took the stand there was an enormous reflection on his face protect. I couldn’t see a few of the necessary particulars. I saved peering by means of my binoculars ready for him to show his head. Lastly he did and I used to be in a position to get a superb view of his face. That was such a reduction!

I had heard this was his first time taking the stand, however I’d by no means comprehend it. He was fairly calm, assured, and charismatic. He stated so many optimistic issues about Apple it was simple to love him. Later, I had the chance whereas ending a sketch of him within the hallway to satisfy him. He appears to be a really good man. I used to be shocked to see he has stunning blue eyes. I didn’t notice that whereas sketching him — between the shadow from the sunshine above, the reflection of his visor, and his glasses, his eyes had been obscured. One thing tells me I will probably be sketching him once more since there might be extra Apple trials in my future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.